Bush Administration seeks silence on CIA prisons
Author and Page information
This print version has been auto-generated from http://www.globalissues.org/article/701/bush-administration-seeks-silence-on-cia-prisons
The Washington Post reported (November 4, 2006) that the Bush administration told a federal judge that terrorism suspects held in secret CIA prisons should not be allowed to reveal details of the
alternative interrogation methods that their captors used to get them to talk1.
The Bush administration cited fears that released prisoners may reveal operational/interrogration details or clues to others, thus thwarting the ability to discover plots and methods.
The new court filings asked to even deny the detainees’ own attorneys to hear how their clients have been interrogated. This makes the ability to defend detainees extremely difficult. When the concept of innocent until proven guilty and the right to a fair trial is paramount, this conflict between national security and rights of detainees seem to conflict.
However, in the light of the various torture scandals that have marred the Bush administration’s image lately, this filing can also be criticized for attempting to cover up the use of torture (or
alternative interrogation methods).
Torture is known to be a useless tactic in many cases to illicit information because people will say anything—including admitting to things they have not done—in order for the pain to stop. If more examples of US torture were to come out this way, it could pose a security threat to the US in the sense that some angry people, in places like Iraq, may retaliate with violence and lash out against US targets.
Of course, one way to counter that threat is to not torture in the first place.
Scott Horton, Chair of the International Law Committee at the New York Bar Association, was asked by Democray Now! for his reaction to this, and responded:
This article is part of the following collection:
- US Military Commissions Act 2006—Unchecked Powers?
- “A Total Rollback Of Everything US Has Stood For”: Sen. Patrick Leahy
- Sayonara to Checks and Balances?
- Bush Offers Himself Amnesty for Human Rights Crimes
- US Military Commissions Act 2006—Turning Bad Policy Into Bad Law
- Groups Unanimously Assail New Detention Law
- US War Crimes Act Changes Would Reduce Threat Of Prosecution
- President Bush Acknowledges Secret Prisons
- Outlawed: Extraordinary Rendition, Torture and Disappearances in the “War on Terror”
- Detainee Memo Created Divide in White House
- Bush Administration seeks silence on CIA prisons
- War Crimes Suit Prepared against Rumsfeld
- Bush’s Torture Ban is Full of Loopholes
(Note that listed here are only those hyperlinks to other articles from other web sites or elsewhere on this web site. Other sources such as journal, books and magazines, are mentioned above in the original text. Please also note that links to external sites are beyond my control. They might become unavailable temporarily or permanently since you read this, depending on the policies of those sites, which I cannot unfortunately do anything about.)
- Carol D. Leonnig and Eric Rich, 'U.S. Seeks Silence on CIA Prisons; Court Is Asked to Bar Detainees From Talking About Interrogations', Washington Post, November 4, 2006, http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/11/03/AR2006110301793_pf.html
Back to top