Assam’s Citizenship Crisis: The Politics of Expulsion

  • Opinion by Mohammad Zaman (dhaka, bangladesh)
  • Inter Press Service

DHAKA, Bangladesh, November 18 (IPS) - Assam’s citizenship crisis is not over borders. It is a test of whether citizenship remains a constitutional right or becomes a status that officials may repeatedly place under suspicion. Bengali-speaking Muslims have disproportionately faced reported evictions, electoral-roll deletions, detention and expulsion, while language and faith risk being treated as evidence of doubtful belonging. Recent protests in Delhi against the Election Commission’s leadership have carried that warning to the national stage. The questions are stark: who may vote, who must endlessly prove eligibility, and who pays when the state gets it wrong?

Dr Mohammad Zaman

The official vocabulary—verification, revision, encroachment, expulsion—sounds neutral, but its effects are not. One report estimates that 55,000 people, most of them Bengali Muslims, have been evicted since 2016, including about 6,000 in 2025. Some affected residents were reportedly born in Assam and held voter cards or appeared in the National Register of Citizens. Those records may establish citizenship or electoral status, but they do not, by themselves, establish a right to occupy specific land. Each case requires individual evidence. Even so, a pattern this concentrated cannot be dismissed by labelling everyone affected an “illegal Bengali” from Bangladesh.

Assam’s history is difficult and cannot be wished away: colonial and postcolonial migration, conflict over language and land, and the 1985 Assam Accord all matter. India may regulate immigration and protect public land. What it may not do is blur the difference between an undocumented migrant and a citizen with imperfect papers, or between an unlawful occupant and a family that may be entitled to notice, hearing, rehabilitation or appeal. In the process, India may create its own Rohingya crisis in Assam. As a people, the Bengali Muslims in Assam are fighting for decades for recognition of their rights.

That distinction is being crushed by revived executive expulsion powers. A September 2025 Assam procedure reportedly allowed district officials to label people “illegal immigrants” and order expulsion if they could not prove citizenship within ten days. Analysts warn that officials may decide some cases without first referring them to Foreigners Tribunals, although unresolved cases can still be sent to a tribunal. Rights observers have documented cross-border “pushbacks” without formal deportation orders. When statelessness is the possible result, a ten-day ultimatum is not efficiency. It is due process emptied of meaning.

The electoral roll is now the next frontier of exclusion. Assam’s 2025–26 simplified Special Revision formally relied on door-to-door verification and a claims process, unlike the document-heavy Special Intensive Revision used elsewhere. Yet more than 2,000 people in and around Kachutali, a village located in the Sonapur revenue circle of Kamrup Metropolitan district in Assam, including members of families with long voting histories, were reportedly missing from the revised roll. In one family, a son remained enrolled while his father disappeared from the roll. Such contradictions do not merely reveal bureaucratic sloppiness. They make the ballot look like a favour granted by officials rather than a right secured by law.

That is why the ongoing Delhi protests against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar cannot be waved away as partisan theatre. The Cockroach Janta Party (CJP), student groups, opposition parties and civil-society activists called a protest for 10 October against alleged voter deletions and irregularities in the Special Intensive Revision. The Election Commission did not create Assam’s citizenship regime, and state authorities—not election officials alone—conduct evictions and expulsions. But the Commission cannot hide behind that distinction when credible evidence points to wrongful deletion. It must disclose its methods, explain its decisions and correct errors before citizens lose the chance to vote.

The remedy is neither radical nor complicated. No one should be pushed across a border without a written order, verified nationality, legal representation and meaningful appeal. Eviction from public land must never serve as proof of foreignness. Electoral deletion must require individual notice, stated reasons and a workable route to restoration before polling. The Election Commission and Assam authorities must publish privacy-protected audit data, while independent legal-aid and civil-society observers monitor hearings and removals. Without these safeguards, administrative power becomes punishment without trial.

These demands do not deny Assam’s history or the state’s authority to enforce law. They reject the poisonous idea that identity can substitute for evidence. Bengali speech is not a border document. Muslim faith is not a land record. Poverty is not a confession of foreignness. Rules that look neutral can discriminate when the state knows who is least able to produce archival papers, hire counsel, receive notice or survive years of appeals. Equality before law requires procedures built to prevent that predictable exclusion.

The Delhi protest matters because Assam’s warning is national. Once citizenship can be unsettled by a hurried notice, a missing paper or a mass objection, no border contains the danger. The franchise becomes conditional on bureaucratic stamina, and citizenship becomes a status people must continually re-earn. The Election Commission will not restore credibility by demanding trust. It must earn trust through reasons, corrections, independent scrutiny and a presumption that no eligible voter should be excluded because the state’s own records are fractured.

The choice is not between indigenous security and minority rights. That is the false binary on which exclusion feeds. Assam can protect land, language and lawful borders without turning Bengali-speaking Muslims into permanent defendants in the court of national belonging. The constitutional question is not whether the state may identify a foreign national, revise a roll or remove an unlawful encroachment. It is whether power is constrained by evidence, hearing, proportionality and effective appeal—and whether officials answer for failure. A republic reveals its character not in slogans but in its treatment of those easiest to dispossess. If administrative suspicion is allowed to do the work that open discrimination cannot, every citizen’s rights are weakened. The state must not be permitted to convert prejudice into procedure and call the result lawful. Citizenship cannot remain meaningful if officials can erase it in practice before the law has proved otherwise.

Dr. Mohammad Zaman has closely followed the plight of Bengali-speaking Muslims since the controversial 2019 citizenship-screening drive and has written several op-eds examining how Assamese media have unfairly portrayed them as Bangladeshis. He can be reached at mqzaman.bc@gmail.com

IPS UN Bureau

© Inter Press Service (20261118055409) — All Rights Reserved. Original source: Inter Press Service

Where next?

Advertisement